BRC presses MPs on business rates for high streets
For retailers deciding whether to keep, refit or close shops, the question is what they will actually pay. That was the point the British Retail Consortium (BRC) took to Parliament this week. The BRC said that on 17 November its chief executive, Helen Dickinson, appeared before the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee as part of its inquiry into revitalising England's high streets.
According to the BRC's account, published on 19 November by Daniel Bellis, its head of property and finance, the discussion ranged from business rates reliefs and landlord liability to fiscal devolution and the challenges of taxing online sales.
The final bill, not the multiplier
The BRC said it pointed MPs to a tax burden that has risen by 20% to £41 billion and 120,000 job losses. It also argued that changes to individual multipliers can hide what retailers pay once reliefs and transitional arrangements are applied, and said this leaves retail paying £1.1 billion more following April's revaluation. These are the trade body's own figures. The page does not say what period the 20% rise covers.
The BRC's main request was clear. In its words, "no shop should pay more in business rates". It also wants reform that does not shift the burden from one part of retail to another. It said its pre-Budget priorities included cancelling the CPI uplift and removing shops from the high-value multiplier, and that improving an existing property should not raise its rates bill.
Who really pays
The most useful part of the session for property teams may be the debate about landlords. The BRC said MPs explored whether landlords should be liable for business rates, and whether reliefs end up in higher rents rather than helping occupiers. The BRC rejected both easy answers. Where demand is weak, it argued, landlords cannot simply raise rents to absorb relief. But making landlords liable could also bring the cost back to retailers through rents, along with extra costs if landlords hire specialists. As the BRC put it: "Moving responsibility for the bill is not the same as reducing the burden."
What to watch
The limits matter here. This is a lobby group's own summary of its evidence, not the committee's record or its conclusions. It did not include new costings or a timetable. The real test is whether the committee's eventual report, and any government response, actually lowers the total cost of occupying a shop or just moves it around.
The BRC set out a test that retail finance and property leaders could apply to any proposal: will it lower the cost of occupying retail premises, make future liabilities more predictable and give businesses greater confidence to invest? Until there are firm proposals, it is wise to plan estates on today's liabilities, not on the hope of reform.
